I thought that was a pretty stupid argument, really, because it's the final product that matters. The look of the film, however it's done, is still the cinematographer's vision in my mind. People said the same when color film came in, didn't they? The world evolves, and image-making evolves.
Roger Deakins quote
Advertisement
More from Roger Deakins
-
When you move the camera, or you do a shot like the crane down (in Shawshank) with them standing on the edge of the roof, then it's got to mean something. You've got to know why you're doing it; it's got to be for a reason within the story, and to further the story.
-
To me if there's an achievement to lighting and photography in a film it's because nothing stands out, it all works as a piece. And you feel that these actors are in this situation and the audience is not thrown by a pretty picture or by bad lighting.
-
Someone said to me, early on in film school... if you can photograph the human face you can photograph anything, because that is the most difficult and most interesting thing to photograph.
-
I don't really believe in the mystery of cinematography - what happens in the camera is what the cinematographers create and all that nonsense.
-
I think of filmmaking as a form of communication. Maybe it's also an art, but that's for somebody else to decide.
-
Maybe that sounds a bit pretentious, but I think life experience is always more important than technical knowledge.